Its good to see the face of the MGB with just those 3 panels bolted up
That wing to door edge gap is the same sort of issue with pattern wings for mk2 Granadas. Only on them its the wing that isnt correctly shaped
Will the door skin replacement get reformed at that portion to reduce the gap?
From experience attempting to reform the edge to reduce the gap is a problem - you largely distort the profile on the curvature on the door skin and also run out of flange edge to fold back over the door frame due to the fact you have extended it - to close the gapping - Its much better to fit the skin has it is and then then extend the skin by adding to it in order to close the gapping - there's a few tricks that make this an easy process that I will detail once I get the doors reskinned / rehung
Mmm. Interesting. Just have to wait and see. I remember a post on another forum (before this one started) which might have been Chris. I think it was a VW Type 2 with a large gap between the door and front panel beautifully corrected by welding in a bit of round bar.
From experience attempting to reform the edge to reduce the gap is a problem - you largely distort the profile on the curvature on the door skin and also run out of flange edge to fold back over the door frame due to the fact you have extended it - to close the gapping - Its much better to fit the skin has it is and then then extend the skin by adding to it in order to close the gapping - there's a few tricks that make this an easy process that I will detail once I get the doors reskinned / rehung
Mmm. Interesting. Just have to wait and see. I remember a post on another forum (before this one started) which might have been Chris. I think it was a VW Type 2 with a large gap between the door and front panel beautifully corrected by welding in a bit of round bar.
Blimy that's a few years ago - That will be this one then
Post by grumpynorthener on Jun 2, 2021 21:05:23 GMT
Bonnet back off and some more tweaking
Unfortunately some of the damage I just cant get to / work from the underside due to the underframe
There are advantages to fitting panels to a bare bodyshell
You can place the bonnet in the correct closed location
Then access the hinge bolts to tighten them up through the underside of the empty engine bay reduces all the effort of open & closing the bonnet then adjusting the fit to the hinges
I fitted the bonnet locking pin & spring
Along with the catch to the slam panel
But the pin will not engage with the catch - its too short because the bonnet underframe has been forced upwards & out of alignment - it would be a heap of trouble attempting to get this back aligned
I went about it from a different angle and extended the length of the pin
Placement of some temporary bonnet buffers on the wing edges (blue pads)
And we have a locking bonnet
That isn't too far away from where it needs to be
Front edge is slightly out of alignment but its sortable
I shall compare this fit to another bonnet that Sam has and go from there
Offside door is next
Door skin is perforated all the way across the bottom
And is also letting go on the top edge
And splitting on the rear top edge
It could be repaired buts its a lot of faff when door skins are readily available for reasonable money
Bottom of the door frame is also suffering from perforation - Don't think that I have covered removing / fitting a door skin on any of my threads so for completeness I will run through the process tomorrow - if you have one to do or would like to know how its done then you have detailed account - more tomorrow then
Post by grumpynorthener on Jun 3, 2021 20:46:10 GMT
Easy way to remove a door skin is to run around the flange edge of the skin with a flap disc on a angle grinder - take care though not to go too deep and start to reduce the edge of the door frame
Expect to find a few spotwelds and in some cases small areas of brazing but the skin should come away from the frame quite easily
Skin removed from the frame - note the offset datums marked before the door frame bottom is removed
Removed
Repair section trial fitted
Then tack welded insitu
New door skin then trial fitted to the door frame
Skin panels can be vulnerable to damage so I would always recommend using protection between the jaw of the clamp and the skin - a piece of scrap steel is fine - I would also ensure that you check that the replacement skin is identical - manufactures often make minor changes to swage profiles / door handles / locks etc which results in different apertures - the skin may well fit the door frame but you may find that its for completely different door furniture / fittings
Door skin back off and the new door bottom welded in
Then dressed back
I used the removed section along with the nearside door to mark up any aperture holes for the door card clips & the drain holes
Then refitted the door skin
Then its a matter of dressing the flange edge of the new skin over the top of the door frame - there's a few gadgets / tools in the market advocating that they are great for this job - frankly I have always found them useless so I stick with the hammer & dolly method
Steady - methodical progress is required - keep the dolly firm & tight against the outer face of the door skin
Firm hammer blows are required but take care not to distort the skin or door frame (which is easily done)
The clamps can be removed as you work your way around the frame
Before I weld the skin to the frame its always a good idea to trial fit the door back to the aperture (note my use of drill bits for hinge locations - previously drilled before I removed the door)
Critical path here is that the horizontal swage aligns with the front & rear wings
Top radius needs work but I expected that
Front vertical gapping requires a little correction
Rear vertical gapping is a mile out - so was the previous skin - the rear wing edge is partly made up with lead loading eventually in the profiling stages - door edge on the skin will also require some work but later down the line
Door to sill gapping also needs work
This is a pattern panel hence I wasn't expecting a perfect fit - I hear that the Heritage panels are no better & given the fit of the original door & skin its no worse than what I started with
Back off with the door and the skin can be tacked to the frame - its all that it needs don't go running long lengths of weld between the skin & the frame
I would however always recommend welding up any mitre corners / splits in the flanges where swages occur - left unwelded you risk possible fractures appearing the door skin over time
Once the flange edges have been fully dressed and the door skin welded in place I normally lightly linish the outer edge of the skin to remove any face marking from the dolly - nothing heavy on the abrasive front - I used 120's and it was literally a light & quick brush over
Door refitted again
Critical opening clearance against the front wing rechecked
You need to remember to allow for the correction of any profiles plus the depth of primers & paints which will alter the clearance tolerance
Temporary offset gapping datums added
Door removed
Weld bead added where I need to close the gapping
Take care if you have a long section to undertake that you don't generate too much heat into the door skin and distort it
If you dress the surface of the weld flush you can then use the offset datum to set the flange edge extension required - marked here with a thin masking tape so that its clearly seen whilst dressing back with a flap disc
Done
Door refitted to the car
Much better gapping alignment
Sid came to give me a second verdict & approval - I'm now awaiting a steel stock delivery before I can complete the remaining gapping modifications
In the interim the bottom of the B post can go back together
Along with the closing panel at the front bottom of the rear wing
Wow. Two nights of catching-up, and what a catch-up. The usual jaw dropping work. As ever, totally impressive. Enjoy the gin, well deserved. It is so interesting to see so many techniques brought together on a single bodyshell. Looking forward to the rest of this one.
Post by grumpynorthener on Jun 4, 2021 6:57:33 GMT
Initially I thought I had the door locking / striker plate set up wrong and had to pack the striker off the B post by nearly 10mm - this is unusual and its normally found on cars that have received accident damage or cars that have been in the hands of an incompetent repairer
But I've been doing some research on the issue and it would appear that they are all like this
Post by grumpynorthener on Jun 4, 2021 20:27:32 GMT
Rear wing & B post panels that were welded in yesterday were dressed back
The closing plate on the rear of the sill cavity has worked out very well too
Small repair to the rear edge of the quarter glass aperture
Then a clean up of the some the original factory welding around the aperture edges (some of which was very poor quality)
Now at a stage where the shell starts to look better by the minute
Still several areas that need addressing through and I hate putting the little jobs off - I'm more of a methodical / tick box / done type of guy
Need to address the tapering alignment of the gapping between the bottom of the front wing & sill
The door needed to come back off so I could address the bottom corner of the A post to the sill
Hinge box removed to allow access to dress the corner up
And make up / weld in the aperture quadrant for the door rubber - this still needs spot welding along the bottom flange edge once the spot welder is back in commission
Door hinges & hinge boxes are identical for the top & bottom - However having achieved a decent fit on the door I would never swap them over - I always mark them to the location - they are removed at the painting stage to allow paint to the underside of the mounting point on the A post but from what I can ascertain the hinges were painted on the car at the factory - even the screw heads are final paint colour
Hinge boxes refitted & the door rehung
Offside rear wing has accident damage on it which has creased the panel
Its been the subject of a previous repair and not a very good one - they have just wacked out what they can quickly then applied thick filler over it - I cant access all of the panel from behind either
There is little swinging room for the hammer too - but a dolly can be utilised to force some of the panel outwards
Dressed out the area that I could access with the hammer & dollies
But still have this area to true up the best that I can
Lightly linished the area
I have this piece of kit - its a slide hammer but with the ability to weld the tip of the puller to the panel
Tacks its self to the panel
Then a few gentle slides back will pull the area of the panel forwards - then just twist about 90 degrees and the tip comes free from the panel
Problem
Soon
Resolved - the little marks that you see are where the tip has been attached to the panel for a pull - You need to be steady & methodical with it - last thing you need to be doing is pulling too far and creating loads of peaks that extend outwards beyond the actual profile of the panel
The invertor puller is fine for single panel skins but no good for double skinned panels
For this I use another trick and weld a pulling tab to the area with which I can use a slide hammer to draw the panel out
Then the tab can be removed and the area dressed back - again you don't want to be applying too much force with the slide hammer and have the panel come too far forward
Then dressed back
Aperture hole in the rear wing was also deleted at the same time - now I still have problem because with the previous repair then my straightening up - the repair area contains metal that has been stretched and the panel is slightly bowing out of profile from where it needs to be - its much better to have a slightly concave area that you can skim fill or lead load rather than have a convex area that you will never loose no mater how much you work it - so I need to shrink the area - there are all sorts of shrinking hammers & dollies on the market - none of which really work that well - ok (ish) for very minor areas but useless in this case
Not for the faint hearted this process - I'm going to loose the excess metal by shrinking with heat - it needs to be a fine flame from a welding torch (please do not attempt this with blow torch etc - you will do more damage than good)
You need to work quickly - heat a small area with the torch (sub 10mm) just has it turns cherry red - remove the flame - the panel will peak outwards - with dolly behind the area tap the area flat with a panel hammer has the area cools it contracts and shrinks - then repeat as required - its much better if you have someone nearby that you can pass the lit torch to quickly whilst you work the hammer & dolly
Then dressed back - the damaged area is now slightly concave - you will never remove all damage and it will require some form of profiling to attain the correct shape - this I will achieve when I undertake the profiles on the car at a later date by initially lead loading then skimming with a profiling filler
That's the offside panels completed with the exception of a few spot welds once the spot welder is sorted and the upper aperture gapping on the door once the steel stock arrives
Rear valance is different on rubber bumpered cars (which this car was) than the chrome bumpered cars (that we are converting it to)
But not by much - a few aperture holes on the chrome bumper valance
And 3 bumper mounting plates on the rubber bumper cars - so remove the 3 plates & make good - drill the bumper mounting apertures for the chrome bumper car in the valance and this one can stay on the car
But it needs straightening up
In a few places
Along with a few minor welded repairs
Initial straightening up completed
And the mounting plates coming off
Spot weld operator was obviously ex army machine gunner
Post by grumpynorthener on Jun 5, 2021 20:19:31 GMT
Rear bumper irons
Mount to the chassis rail where the 2 circular swages are and bolt through the chassis
But I have to drill the bolt holes through the chassis first and its very very tight for drilling space
So tight that I can only just access it with my right angle drill with a cut down then re-sharpened drill bit - took ages to sort / complete
But eventually managed it
Bumper iron then travels through the hole that I drilled in the rear valance
But I was slightly off on the nearside with the aperture hole - it's probably never seen once the bumper is fitted buts this is exactly the type of detail that troubles me if its not done correctly
Sorted
There's a possible argument for fitting a replacement valance rather than modifying the old one - however take a look at the amount of spotwelds to the boot floor through the panel then the risk of distorting the rear panel that the valance is welded to and its a more straight forward process to modify / repair the one that's currently on the car
Most of the welded repairs & aperture holes are now closed up but I ran out of curfew hours for the dressing back with the angle grinder
Nice job Chris! When i got my MGB both door skins were cracked near the quarter lights. I fitted new door skins and welded a strenghening plate inside the door skin near the quarter lights to avoid future cracking. I am not sure if GT s also suffer from those cracks as mine is a roadster and the cracks are often caused by poor fitted windscreen frames which cause stress on the quarterlights which leads to stress on the door skins. I also remember well how difficult it was to do the work on the rear bumper brackets. I also used a angle drill. What i also did is weld in a few pieces of pipe into the chassis rail in the front and rear bumper bracket area. If this is not done, it will be difficult to really tighten the bracket bolt as you will crunch the chassis rail if you really tighten the bolts. What is did not like on MGB s is where the sill meets the rounded B post panel. That area is not welded and i saw rust creeping up on a lot of cars. You can avoid it with seam sealer and waxoil type of stuff by i fully welded it and made a groove afterwards.
I think both of my mums roadsters suffered with the fatigue cracks to the skins , on the second (a rubber bumper) the quarter light frames themselves split too.
Nice job Chris! When i got my MGB both door skins were cracked near the quarter lights. I fitted new door skins and welded a strenghening plate inside the door skin near the quarter lights to avoid future cracking. I am not sure if GT s also suffer from those cracks as mine is a roadster and the cracks are often caused by poor fitted windscreen frames which cause stress on the quarterlights which leads to stress on the door skins. I also remember well how difficult it was to do the work on the rear bumper brackets. I also used a angle drill. What i also did is weld in a few pieces of pipe into the chassis rail in the front and rear bumper bracket area. If this is not done, it will be difficult to really tighten the bracket bolt as you will crunch the chassis rail if you really tighten the bolts. What is did not like on MGB s is where the sill meets the rounded B post panel. That area is not welded and i saw rust creeping up on a lot of cars. You can avoid it with seam sealer and waxoil type of stuff by i fully welded it and made a groove afterwards.
Keep up the good work! Peter
Hi Peter - Many thanks for the comments - I have tube on order for the crush tubes for the bumper bar iron mountings in the chassis rails, roadster door skins have always been a problem with the quarterlight / windscreen fit resulting in panel damage - its not that big a problem on the GT - interesting comment on the panel seam at the base of the B post with the sill - I'll have a look at it - although this shell will have received a decent amount of work to the structure & panels the car really has not had the life that many have and suffered from masses of rust ingress hence the decision to use it rather than a new heritage bodyshell (which still require a lot of work to panel gapping & profiles before they look right)
I think both of my mums roadsters suffered with the fatigue cracks to the skins , on the second (a rubber bumper) the quarter light frames themselves split too.
Pete - Many roadster cars suffer the same problems E types certainly did and to some extent so does the Jupiter
The area below the rear lights and the bumper is different on RB cars, will you be modifying it to give the full Chrome Bumper look? Loving watching the progress.
The area below the rear lights and the bumper is different on RB cars, will you be modifying it to give the full Chrome Bumper look? Loving watching the progress.
Sean
Certainly will - Sam has already supplied me with the parts & a set of lamps to trail fit